ACT Probability Without Replacement: Update the Count Before the Second Draw
Multiply two draws from a small jar, list every equally likely outcome, and see how putting the first slip back changes the second count. Four original questions include the nearby wrong counts.
For two draws in a stated order, multiply the probability of the first result by the probability of the second result after you update the jar. If the first slip goes back, the second probability uses the original counts. If the first slip stays out, the second probability uses the counts that remain. When the question accepts either order, add the probability of each order. A list of every equally likely outcome checks the result.
ACT’s mathematics test description gives Statistics & Probability approximately – of the section. That category includes calculating probabilities and the related sample spaces. The Mathematics Standards include S 603, “Apply counting techniques,” S 604, “Compute a probability when the event and/or sample space are not given or obvious,” and S 605, “Recognize the concepts of conditional and joint probability expressed in real-world contexts.” OpenStax Introductory Statistics 2e, section 3.2, describes sampling with replacement as returning each selected member, so that member can be chosen again and the later probabilities stay the same. Sampling without replacement keeps the selected member out, so each member can be chosen only once and the later probabilities change. OpenStax calls the with-replacement draws independent and the without-replacement draws dependent. The slips, review cards, and tickets below are original Kibo practice.
Decide whether the first slip returns
A folder holds labeled slips. and are orange. and are gray. On every draw, each slip then in the folder is equally likely.
| Rule | First slip | Slips available for the second draw | A repeated slip |
|---|---|---|---|
| With replacement | Returns to the folder | The original | Possible |
| Without replacement | Stays out | The that remain | Impossible for that draw |
List every outcome when the slip stays out
The first slip can be any of the . The second slip can be any of the other . That gives ordered outcomes. A named first slip has probability . A named slip among the three that remain has probability . Every ordered pair of two different slips therefore has probability
Twelve of these probabilities fill the sample space: .
| First slip | Slips that remain | Outcomes |
|---|---|---|
| A | B, C, D | AB, AC, AD |
| B | A, C, D | BA, BC, BD |
| C | A, B, D | CA, CB, CD |
| D | A, B, C | DA, DB, DC |
- Both slips are orange in AB and BA. That is of the outcomes, so the probability is .
- Both slips are gray in CD and DC. That is also .
- One slip is orange and the other is gray in the remaining outcomes: AC, AD, BC, BD, CA, CB, DA, and DB. The probability is .
These three events cover the list: .
Count every outcome when the slip returns
After the color is recorded, the slip goes back and the folder again holds , , , and . Each draw has equally likely slips, so there are ordered outcomes. Each one has probability
and . Rows in the table are the first slip. Columns are the second slip.
| First slip | A | B | C | D |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | AA | AB | AC | AD |
| B | BA | BB | BC | BD |
| C | CA | CB | CC | CD |
| D | DA | DB | DC | DD |
Both draws are orange in AA, AB, BA, and BB. That is . AA and BB are included because the same orange slip can return. Both draws are gray in CC, CD, DC, and DD, which is also . One draw is orange and the other is gray in the other cells, which is . The same three events add to : .
| Event | First slip stays out | First slip returns |
|---|---|---|
| Both orange | ||
| Both gray | ||
| One of each color |
Match each product to the list
The product uses the counts directly. For both orange when the first slip stays out, the first probability is and the second is , because one orange slip remains among the three slips left.
The list has the same outcomes out of . When the slip returns, both factors use the original orange count.
That product matches cells out of . For one of each color, add the two orders. When the first slip stays out,
The first term is orange then gray: AC, AD, BC, and BD. The second term is gray then orange: CA, CB, DA, and DB. When the slip returns, each order has probability , and the two orders add to .
The second factor is conditional. Its denominator is the set of slips still available after the first draw. The conditional probability guide uses that same idea when a two-way table replaces the full group with one row or one column.
Count pairs when the question asks for a set
A student has distinct review cards. Four ask an algebra question, and two ask a geometry question. The student draws two cards. The question asks for the probability that both cards are algebra cards.
When the first card stays out, there are algebra choices and then algebra choices. Any second card has choices.
The question asks for the set of two cards. Each set corresponds to orders, one card first or the other card first. The favorable orders become pairs, and the possible orders become pairs. The same division can be written from the counts directly: the number of ways to choose algebra cards from is , and the number of ways to choose cards from is .
Dividing the favorable orders and the total orders by leaves the probability unchanged. Dividing only the favorable count would use an unordered numerator with an ordered denominator.
When the first card returns, both draws use all cards. Both draws are algebra cards in of the ordered results.
Four of those results use the same algebra card twice. The other use two different algebra cards, in either order. The first factor is under both rules. The second factor is when the card returns and when it stays out. The two products differ by
So is above . The returned card leaves algebra cards available for the second draw, while the removed card leaves .
Try four original practice questions
Exactly one choice answers each question. Each ticket or card remaining in the container is equally likely, and the only rule in effect is the one the question states.
A review game uses tickets: blue and red. A student draws one ticket, sets it aside, and draws a second ticket from those that remain. What is the probability that both tickets are blue?
- A.
- B.
- C.
- D.
The same tickets are used again. The student draws one ticket, returns it, mixes the jar, and draws a second ticket. What is the probability that both draws are blue?
- A.
- B.
- C.
- D.
Using the tickets, the student again sets the first ticket aside before drawing the second. What is the probability that the two tickets have different colors?
- A.
- B.
- C.
- D.
Four note cards are numbered , , , and . A student draws two cards and sets the first card aside. What is the probability that the two numbers add to ?
- A.
- B.
- C.
- D.
Show answers and checks
Choice B. The first blue probability is . One blue ticket remains among the tickets left, so the second probability is .
There are favorable orders and possible orders. Choosing a set gives the same fraction: blue pairs and pairs, so .
- Choice A is . Both factors use the original blue tickets, which is the result when the first ticket returns.
- Choice C is . The numerator drops to blue tickets, while the denominator stays at the original .
- Choice D is . The second denominator is the original number of blue tickets. The red tickets are still in the jar, so tickets remain.
Choice D. The returned ticket leaves blue tickets among all .
There are favorable orders and possible orders.
- Choice A is , the probability from question 1, where the first ticket stays out.
- Choice B is . It lowers the blue count and keeps the original denominator.
- Choice C is , the probability that the first draw is blue.
Choice A. Blue then red and red then blue are different orders.
The matching-color probability is , from both blue and both red. The two color patterns cover every outcome: . Also, .
- Choice B is , the blue-then-red order by itself.
- Choice C is , the probability that the two tickets have the same color.
- Choice D is . That sum is one of each color when the first ticket returns.
Choice C. The ordered draws that add to are , , , and . There are ordered draws, so the probability is .
The pairs are with , with , with , with , with , and with . Two of those pairs add to , and .
- Choice A is . It puts the unordered successes over the ordered outcomes.
- Choice B is . The successful orders are still the ones that add to , and orders are possible when the first card returns. The doubles , , , and add to , , , and .
- Choice D is . It divides the successful pairs by the cards.
Name the rule before the second fraction
- Copy the sentence that says whether the first slip returns.
- Write the first probability from the counts in the full container.
- If the slip returns, write the second probability from those same counts.
- If the slip stays out, remove it, then write the second probability from what remains.
- Multiply the two probabilities. When either order meets the question, add the orders.
- Count the equally likely outcomes and compare that count with the product.
If the result misses, record whether the jar was updated, whether both orders were added, or whether an unordered count was paired with an ordered total. The practice error log keeps that note for a later recheck.
Try a free ACT practice question with Kibo, and name what the first draw does to the container before you write the second count.
Prepared with AI assistance. The listed outcomes, products, pair counts, and every practice choice were checked with separate exact arithmetic. No human review or score improvement is claimed. Sources checked November 16, 2026. This guide is not affiliated with or endorsed by ACT.